I finally FINALLY got around to watching the first episode of Sherlock (from BBC) on Netflix. Those who know me know by now that I absolutely ADORE Sherlock Holmes and everything related to him, and I knew for a fact that I would love Sherlock. It was just a matter of finding the time to actually sit down and watch it, and that certainly wasn’t going to happen during the semester. But today I finally made some time and sat down during lunch to watch the first episode.
And let me just say, though I already knew I would love it, I was seriously impressed by how incredible it was. The writers did such a fantastic job of updating the characters and the story without losing any of what makes Sherlock Holmes and John Watson so completely awesome. The show was sharp, quick-paced, funny in all the right ways. It helps that Steven Moffat was one of the creators.
I completely understand the appeal and obsession of Benedict Cumberbatch. I mean, I’d heard he was good, and I’d certainly seen enough pictures and commercials to know he was good-looking, but it was nice to finally see first-hand how well he handled the character of Sherlock Holmes. His mannerisms and facial expressions were very well-done. I loved his face when he the cops come to do a drug-search in his apartment, John tries to defend by saying he couldn’t possibly be the type to have drugs, and Sherlock is trying to get him to shut up. HILARIOUS! Also, on a random note, he voice was much deeper than I would have guessed it to be judging by his face.
And I already loved Martin Freeman, but now I absolutely ADORE him. He was an inspired casting choice for John Watson. He gave the character just the right balance of sympathy and vulnerability, with an intelligence that is clearly sharp but obviously not on par with Sherlock, and a bit of calm, collected, bad-ass soldier-ness to top it all off.
I also really liked Lestrade. I was so glad they didn’t make him a total idiot, as some versions are wont to do with the character. I mean, it’s always amusing when the Lestrade character is just a bumbling idiot, but in a modern-day police force it is not entirely believable for a detective to be complete moron. He can be far inferior to Sherlock (and often out of his depth), and it’s still possible to be a capable police officer. I’m glad the writers realized that.
I was a bit surprised that they made mention of Moriarty so quickly. The big-boss bad guy is usually something you save for awhile. But then again, considering the first season is only 3 episodes long (the British are so weird about their extra-short tv seasons), I guess it’s not so surprising after all.
I confess, however, that I was a bit put off by how slow Sherlock was to figure out the killer was a taxi driver. The very first time he said something to the effect of: “who do we trust even though we don’t know them? Who can hunt in a crowded city without being noticed?” etc… I said out-loud: “a taxi driver, duh!” I thought for sure Sherlock was just leading John along, trying to get him to come to the conclusion himself, but no! He said he didn’t know. Then they chase down a taxi and I think, for sure, Sherlock had figured it out, but no: he questions the passenger, not the taxi driver! It didn’t click until the taxi driver is standing right in front of him half an hour later! Come on! He should have had that figured out WAY more quickly than that. I get that the writers were trying to keep the audience in suspense, but if I could figure it out that easy, there’s no way Sherlock wouldn’t have.
Anyway, I’m so glad I FINALLY got around to seeing this. I’ll definitely be watching the next episode shortly. Like, probably tonight… It’s sad that Netflix only has the first season on streaming though. I’ll have to find the second season somewhere else.